My great great grandmother's mother was Cornelia Gardner, according to family records and death certificates. For the last 20 years I have been trying to figure out how she connects. I believe I found the answer. Research led me to the information below, but shared DNA with Trahern descendants and multiple Gardner's does seem to confirm it. (Note, this is not including descendants of Jeremiah Gardner and Sarah Hall as they are relatives on the Trahern side (Sarah Hall is the Aunt of Sarah Hall who married James Trahern).
Samuel (Sam Gardner), son of John Gardner and Alatoma in 1855 had wife Mary and a family in Towson. In 1868, his family includes another daughter (under 16) and a male age 10-16 without a wife. In 1868/1869 he married Isabelle Durant and had one more child, a son Basil Gardner born in 1869.
By the time of the Dawes, Samuel has died, as has all his children, except Basil.
The children I have for Samuel Gardner and wife Mary are:
Nancy Gardner born about 1849, she was not alive at the time of the dawes, and it is unknown if she married.
Loring Nolen Gardner born about 1851. He had son Pittman Gardner b 1873 and two daughters, Surena Gardner b 1880 who married John Wright, Wesley Phillips and Jimmie Coleman, and Millie Gardner who died before 1899. The mother of the girls was Mary Yale.
Sissy Gardner who was on the 1855 Annuity role is not listed in the household in 1868. She either died or married and if she did marry, was not alive by 1899.
Cornelia Gardner born about 1860 married Robert Trahern. Cornelia died in 1892. She had Admona (Addie), Margaret, Czarina (Rena), Loren, Martha and William Trahern.
The child of Samuel and Isabelle was Basil Gardner married Mary Ann Baker and had Edmond, Jefferson L, Laura Jane, Etta May, Adam Arrie, Sarah and Josephine Gardner.
As a side note, Clarissa Leflore cannot be the wife of Jeremiah Gardner
as his son marries her daughter. There is an error in an old interview
on that item. Sarah Hall, the sister of William Hall (married Susan
Riddle) and Margaret Hall (married John Ring and A.W. Geary) was married
to Jeremiah Gardner in Marengo County, Alabama June 21, 1818. Jerry
Gardner is found near the Hall's on the Armstrong roll. We do not know
which white man named Hall is the father of these children. Of note, Margaret Hall could already read and write when she tutored girls at the missionary school in before 1825. She was significantly younger than her sister Sarah and brother William by about 7 years.
1831
Armstrong Rolls
Nittakechi
District
James
Gardner 11, 2 males over 16, 3 children under 10, one slave
John
Gardner 5, 2 males over 16, one child under 10
William
Gardner, 11, 4 males over 16, 5 children under 10
Mushulatubbee
District
Jeremiah
Gardner, 7, one male over 16, 4 children
James
Grant, 2, one white, notation married Gardner’s daughter since treaty (this is an error, he married Gardner's sister in law Margaret Hall July 28, 1831 in Marengo).
Attended
Choctaw Academy
James
Gardner age 9, 1832
Noel
Gardner 1829 {approx 17}
Emigration
information
Ft.
Towson ? year {Volume 2 of emigration book}
James Gardner 45, Margaret 35, Noel {Newell} 20,
Rebecca 17, Lucy 15, Sally 12, Mary 10, Bob 8, Edmond 3
John
Gardner 23, Alatima 25, Solomon 3
Lewis
Gardner 30, Viscey 18, Joseph 1 ½
Isaac
Gardner 35, Rebecca 20, Sarah 8 Zachariah 3, Eliza 1 Slaves Polly 11, Solomon 2
William
Gardner 34, Betsy 35, Jackson 12, Sinai 9, Eliza 7, Hote ? 6, Anna 4, Sampson 1
Silas,
James and John Gardner households
Gardner
Head of Household's that immigrated in 1831-1833 (no idea who belongs to which
family, not listed on the transcription)
James
45
William
34
Lewis
30
John
23 {son of James}
Jerry
(no age, would be at least 40) Mushulatubbe district
Isaac
35
Women
Alatima
25, {John}
Betsy
age 35, {wife of william}
Margaret
35, {wife of James}
Rebecca
20, {wife of Isaac}
Viscey
18 {Wife of Lewis}
Children,
Solomon
{2}, 2 {slave} and 3 {son of John},
Sinai,
9, {William}
Sarah
8, {Isaac}
Sampson
1, {William}
Sally
12, {james}
Polly,
11, {Slave Isaac}
Newell,
{probably Noel, James} 20,
Mary,
10, {James}
Lucy,
15, {James}
Lote,
6, {william}
Joseph
1, {Lewis}
Jackson
12, {this is the Jackson in 1855, William}
Eliza
{2} 7 and 1, {Isaac father of one age 1, William is father of one age 7}
Edmund
3, {This is the Edmund in 1855, son of James}
Bob
8, {James}
Anna
4 {William}
Rebecca 17, James
1855
census Apuckshunnubbee District
Towson
121 Sam Gardner M *** This is I believe the father of Cornelia Gardner
Mary F
Nancy F
Loring C
Sissey [Sipey?] C
127 Edmund Gardner M
Lucy Gardner F
Tum-mey F
Robert C
Dixon C
Phebe C
Lavinia C
Sophia C
227 Billy Gardner M
Betsey F
Louis C
Simpson C
250 Noel Gardner M
Anna Gardner (LeFlore] F
Jefferson C
Jerry C
Simon C
Jemmey [Jenney?] C
Narcissa C
273 Col. Geo. W. Harkins M
Selina Harkins [Gardner] F
Cornelia Harkins F
O.B. Harkins C
Louis E. Harkins C
Loring F. Harkins C
Susan
Harkins C
Cathrine Harkins C
Pushmataha
Blue
353 Sarah Gardner
Lucy Ann
Joseph
Albert
354 William Gardner
Mary [Wilson]
Salina
Clarissa
Rodolfus
Sarah Ann
364 Calvin Gardner
Elizabeth
452 Laura
Jane Gardner
Kiamitia
241 Feilding Gardner
Elatiya
Cornelius
Forbes
Sabil
Morris
Arinson
Noah
Chickasaw
District
30 Jackson Gardner
Mary Gardner
Simeon
Abiline
Alfred
Jesse
Josiah
Harriet
91 Isaac Gardner
Rebecca Gardner [Johnson]
George
Silas
Harriet
James
Sally
Christopher
Reuben
Blasom
Bideseab
Hannah
96 Zachariah Gardner
Levina Gardner [McKinney]
Joseph
Alkinson
Phebe
1885
Choctaw Census
Blue
Gardner,
R.C., 3, MI, Farmer, Blue
Gardner,
William, 4, MI, , Blue
Gardner,
Arthur, 2, MI, , Blue
Gardner,
Arena, 22`, FI, , Blue
Gardner,
Lelia, 15, FI, , Blue
169.
Gardner, Samuel, 22, MI, Farmer, Blue
Gardner,
G.W., 41, MI, Farmer, Blue
Gardner,
Edward, 14, MI, , Blue
Gardner,
Daniel, 12, MI, , Blue
Gardner,
Robert, 8, MI, , Blue
Gardner,
Willie, 6, MI, , Blue
Gardner,
Arabella, 30, FI, , Blue
Gardner,
Esebell, 16, FI, , Blue
Gardner,
Mary, 10, FI, , Blue
Gardner,
Dona, 3, FI, , Blue
Gardner,
Samuel, 55, , Farmer, Blue
Gardner,
Bazil, 15, M, , Blue
Gardner,
Moley, 62, , , Blue
Hleohtabe,
Seely, 15, FI, , Blue
Holton,
McKinney, 21, M, , Blue
Gardner,
Edmund W., 32, MI, Farmer, Blue
Gardner,
Jane, 25, FI, , Blue
Gardner,
E.C. Vina, 14, FI, , Blue
Gardner,
Zachariah, 12, MI, , Blue
Gardner,
Ezekiel, 9, MI, , Blue
Gardner,
Nancy, 2, FI, , Blue
Gardner,
Lucinda, 1, FI, , Blue
Gardener,
Wm Sr., 54, MI, Farmer, Blue
Gardner,
Mary, 61, FI, , Blue
Gardner,
Sarah, 22, FI, , Blue
Gardner,
Jane, 14, FI, , Blue {?granddaughter or daughter or daughter of George and
Phoebe?}
Gardner,
Wm Jr., 5, MI, , Blue {grandson}
Gardner,
Jesse, 35, MI, Farmer, Blue
Gardner,
Wilson, 9, MI, , Blue
Gardner,
Margaret, 7, FI, , Blue
Gardner,
William, 19, MI, , Blue
Gardner,
Noel, 17, MI, , Blue
Gardner,
Alonzo, 11, MI, , Blue
Tobusky
Gardner,
Joe, 31, M/I, Farmer, 40 ac.
Gardner,
Sally, 24, F/I, ,
Gardner,
Francis, 6, F/I,
Sanbois
Garland,
Suky, 50, F/I, ,
Gardner,
Louisa, 16, F/I, ,
Nail,
Nicholas, 12, M/I, ,
Hancock,
Albert L., 7, M/I, ,
Hancock,
Lorin, 4, M/I, ,
Eagle
Gardner,
Jefferson, 40, MI, Merchant,
Gardner,
Julia, 22, FI, ,
Gardner,
Eliza, 13, FI, ,
Gardner,
John, 6, MI, ,
Gardner,
Willy (?), 4, MI, ,
Gardner,
Emma, 2, FI, ,
Tohnika,
Anderson, 36, MI, , 21
Tohnika,
Jincy, 30, MI (sic), ,
Tohnika,
Sisteon, 9, FI, ,
Tohnika,
Elsy, 7, FI, ,
Mamby,
Pickman, 18, Mi, ,
Gardner,
Scott, ½, MI, ,
Towson
Gardner,
Jerry, 38, FI, Farmer
Gardner,
Jincy, 28, FI,
Gardner,
Noel, 11, MI,
Gardner,
Alfred, 9, MI,
Gardner,
Edmond, 7, MI,
Gardner,
Jimmy, 5, MI,
Gardner,
Melinda, 1, FI,
Gardner,
Loraine, 34, MI, Farmer (Loring)
Gardner,
Mary Ann, 31, FI,
Gardner,
Pitman, 12, MI,
Gardner,
Susan Ann, 5, FI,
Garner,
Miley, 1, FI,
Dawes
card database (accessgenealogy.com)
Those
in red are unaccounted for… some are IW and probably not choctaw
Gardner’s
on Dawes
81
Zachariah Gardner, 69, ½, Isaac and Rebecca Gardner
97
James W. Gardner, 49, 3/8 Isaac and Rebecca Gardner
112
Mary Jane Gardner Florence, 40, 3/8, George and Phoebe Gardner
124
Viney Gardner Gray, 29, ½ George and Phoebe Gardner
153
Emma Lee Gardner Williams, 19, 3/16, James W. and Emily Gardner
157
Benjamin Gardner, 21, 1/16, J.W. and Emily Gardner
167
Julia D. Gardner Campbell, 41, ¾, Silas and Hettie Gardner
366
Robert Gardner 21, William Dempsey Gardner, 16, ¼, G.G. and Francis Gardner
387
Children of Jessie D. Gardner and Minnie Scroggins
446
Rebecca Gardner Kirkland, 27, ¼, George and Phoebe Gardner
560
Jefferson Gardner, 55, ½, Noel and Lucy Gardner
568
Elzira Gardner Christy, 26, Full, Jefferson and Lucinda Gardner
626
Margaret Gardner Watson, 28, Full, Edmund and Liza Gardner
973
Estella Hutcherson, 14, ½, Jim Hutcherson and Clara Gardner
974
Carrie Gardner, 12, Full, Jerry and Jenny Gardner
1087
Surena Gardner Wright, 19, Full, Nolen and Mary Ann Gardner
1141
Wyles Gardner, 22, Full, ? Gardner and Becky Austin
1305
Edmond Gardner, 22, ½, Jerry and Jinnie Gardner
1315
Alfred Gardner, 23, ½ Jerry and Jenny Gardner
1354
Need card to discern four people with three sets of parents on card
1368
Anderson Gardner, 25, Full, Tanisee, Tonawahoke
1392
Josephine Gardner Terry, 21, 3/8, Jimmie Gardner and Agnes Bohannon
1423
Lucinda Gardner Ward, 18, Full, Edmund and Selina Gardner
1431
Edmond Gardner, 45, Full, George and Lucinda Gardner
1436
Israel Gardner, 23, Full, Edmond and Lucy Gardner
1462
Zachariah Gardner, 28, Full, Edmond and Lucy Gardner
1580
Eunice Gardner Pisachube, 49, Full, Jackson and Viney Gardner
2439
Malissa Harrison Garland, 59, ¼, William Harrison and Becky Gardner
2572
Louisa Gardner McDaniel, 31, ½, Edmund and Sukey Gardner
3379
Basil L. Gardner, 30, ¾, Samuel and Isabelle Gardner
3381
Sarah A. Gardner Hardage, 38, 1/8, William and Mary Gardner
3405
Wilson Gardner, 24, ¾, Jesse and Becky Gardner
3418
Jessie J. Gardner, 50, ¾, Jackson and Mary Gardner
3428
Adeline Gardner Tyree, 20, ¾, J.J. and Rebecka Gardner
3458
William Gardner, 19, ¼, Adolphus and Carrie Gardner (Living with Mary Wilson
Gardner)
3477
Sam Gardner, 70, Full, John Gardner (card would be helpful)
3530
Alfred W. Gardner, 51, ¾, Jackson and Mary Gardner
3548
Rose E. Florence Gardner, 21, IW, Robert and Josephine Gardner
3558 Lon
Gardner, 25, Full, Simeon and Harriet Gardner
3559
Rudolphus C. Gardner, 45, 3/8, William and Mary Gardner
3698
Raymond R. Gardner, 3, ¼, Daniel and Mary J. Gardner
3732
Wilson Gardner, 17, Full {no parents on database}
3776
Samuel G. Gardner, 35, ½, Green and Harriet Gardner
3806
Daniel H. Gardner, 25, Full, Green and Arabella Gardner
3807
Children of Green Gardner and Arabella Folsom
3809
Edward N. Gardner, 27, Full, Green Gardner
3810
Mary A. Gardner Riddle, 23, Full, Green and Arabella Gardner
3957 Rosetta
Gardner, 20, 1/8, Samuel and Mantha (Martha?) Riddle (She is listed on card
3809 as IW, parents and name and age same)
4346
Need card to discern information, looks like granddaughter of Jackson and Mary
Gardner on card, Rebecca Jackson, 23, ¾ mother Harriet
4767
Need card, looks like, Nancy B. Gardner Haight, 19, ½, Edmund and Jane Gardner,
who had children Critten A. Gardner, 4, and Winnie J. Gardner, 1, ½, with R.C.
Gardner
4820
Catherine Gardner Fulton, 41, ½, Silas and Elizabeth Gardner
4827
Josiah Gardner, 50, Full, Jackson and Mary Gardner
5157 Margaret
L. Gardner Wheat, 15, NR, J.M. and Sally Gardner
5162
Card not clear, J.M. Gardner indian wife with his children, wife deceased
5663
Zora McDaniel Gardner, 19, IW, Richard and Eliz McDaniel
5688
Card not clear
5703
Nodie Gardner, 12, ¼, James Gardner and Ida Wright
5845
Card not clear
5968
Rosetta Gardner, 7, ¼, Wilson W. Gardner, and Zona Webb
Cemeteries
http://ftp.rootsweb.com/pub/usgenweb/ok/johnston/cemeteries/armstrng.txt
http://ftp.rootsweb.com/pub/usgenweb/ok/bryan/cemeteries/gardner.txt
http://ftp.rootsweb.com/pub/usgenweb/ok/mccurtain/cemeteries/valupton.txt
http://ftp.rootsweb.com/pub/usgenweb/ok/bryan/cemeteries/pleasant.txt
http://ftp.rootsweb.com/pub/usgenweb/ok/latimer/cemeteries/cem000gh.txt
http://ftp.rootsweb.com/pub/usgenweb/ok/mccurtain/cemeteries/bokhoma.txt
http://ftp.rootsweb.com/pub/usgenweb/ok/pushmataha/cemeteries/finlycem.txt
notes below were compiled about 15 years ago.